Thursday, September 04, 2008

We're all Ghouls Now

I just watched the "Tribute to 9/11 victims" they ran tonight, the last night of the Republican National Convention. And a great deal became clear to me. They present the attacks on America, and on Americans, as if they have no basis, no history, no reason, they are just a bunch of Muslims who hate us for no good reason. Maybe they just don't have anything better to do, they don't drink beer, so when they get bored they think "Hey, I dunno, there's nothing on TV, let's go kill some Americans".

Their response is we have to fight them. But it's so clear that that's stupid. It's so obvious that killing them, invading and occupying their countries, assassinating their leaders and starving their populations will only create more fighters who hate, not America, but American policies, and will continue to try to change those policies. Again, it's obvious that they don't have the leverage, the political or military or economic wherewithal to try to make America and The West and the UN LISTEN to their grievances, so they can see no option but to attack assymetrically, in the only way available to them.

Finally, at long last, to any thinking person, the answer is obvious. To try to kill them is to perpetuate the conflict. To try to find a way to live in peace with them, to respect their rights, their countries and their beliefs, to help them out of poverty, to help them educate their people and eradicate disease and develop their economies, these are a path to peace between our people.

Honestly, this is not really complex. Disgustingly, our governement recognizes these self-evident truths. But to coexist in peace with the Islamic Nations is not the goal. No more than the goal was ever to end the occupation of Iraq. The goal is a permanant state of war, and the costs in lives and treasure don't seem to matter.

What's truly important at this point is we stop providing cover to the parties on both sides who profit in so many ways from eternal warfare. Both bush/cheney and bin laden/zawahiri are quite happy with the current state of affairs. Neither can be concerned with the lives lost, the lives ruined, the hopeless, the homeless, the stateless.

When the answer is easy and it's hard to prolong the status quo, and yet the status quo is prolonged and the people aren't asking the simple, obvious questions, there's something truly wrong with the system. When the war destroys families and families don't actively work to end the war, when people rail against waste and ignore the waste of fighting a war that would simply end if we just quit fighting it - when death, poverty and disease is accepted and any peace intitiative is seen as weakness, it's the society itself that is sick.

4 Comments:

At 4:59 PM, Blogger Jennifer said...

It's the leaders and the political system that is sick. People are soft, too. Or too busy to do anything about it. They tend to go along with the system, rather than oppose it.

 
At 2:53 PM, Blogger Brian Harber said...

Or maybe it's that Obama and the left are naive. We just can't figure out why they are attacking us...it must be our deodorant or maybe our love of freedom. That's it, they are jealous of our freedoms. PSHHHH....Seriously...

 
At 4:18 PM, Blogger mikey said...

Y'know, I've NEVER heard the "they hate us for our freedoms" from anybody who wasn't a FAR RIGHT hack. You know, like bush/cheney.

Typically, the complaint about the left is we don't want to fight them, we just want to prosecute them.

I don't know how true that is overall, but the thing about it is that terrorism IS a law enforcement and intelligence problem, NOT a military problem

 
At 8:36 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

[...]NOT a military problem.

And on those rare occasions when it is, it calls for the application of a scalpel instead of a club. See Entebbe, Iranian Embassy in 1980, etc.

Unfortunately, it's a pretty short list of more-or-less desirable outcomes. See also Beslan, Waco, etc.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home